A little discovery can begin with something that is not quite perfect.
The green tourmaline in this video has a lovely colour, an elegant emerald cut and a visible inclusion. That combination prompted a thought from our co-founder, Tay Kunming: “There are no ugly gems, just gems with mismatched purpose.”
At The Gem Museum Shop, we think it is a useful starting point for anyone beginning a collection. Look closer, ask questions and discover what makes a particular gem the right choice for you.
A closer look at an inclusion
An inclusion is a feature inside a gemstone. Depending on the stone, it might be a small crystal, a growth feature or another internal characteristic.
Some are difficult to see without magnification. Others are visible when you simply look at the gem. Their size, position and nature matter: an inclusion can affect appearance, and some features also affect how safely a stone can be handled or used in jewellery.
In green tourmaline, distracting visible inclusions can reduce market value. GIA’s tourmaline quality guide explains this expectation. That helps us understand a price difference, while leaving room to appreciate a stone’s colour, cutting and individual character.
A video is a starting point for observation. If you are considering a gemstone for jewellery, ask about the actual stone and its suitability before planning a setting.
Begin with what you want to discover
A collection can begin with one specimen that catches your attention.
Perhaps you want to explore green gems. Perhaps you enjoy comparing crystal shapes, or you want something you can examine with your child. Another collector may be looking specifically for a faceted tourmaline with excellent clarity.
Those are different aims, and they call for different choices.
The tourmaline in our video might interest someone who enjoys its colour and emerald cut. A collector seeking a stone with no visible inclusions may decide to keep looking. Someone building an introductory mineral collection may prefer a less costly specimen and save the rest of their budget for other discoveries.
The stone stays the same. What changes is how well it fits the collection.
Quality describes characteristics we can examine. Suitability brings your purpose and budget into the decision.
A lower price can open a different kind of discovery
A gem with a visible inclusion may appeal to fewer buyers seeking high clarity. At a different price, it can become interesting to someone who prioritises other features.
That does not make every inexpensive gem a good buy. Ask what you are getting, what you are accepting and whether you will enjoy owning it.
If you love a gem’s colour and shape, accepting a visible inclusion might make sense for a display collection. If the feature distracts you every time you look, a lower price may not make it the right choice.
Likewise, paying more for a stone with better clarity only helps if that improvement matters to your purpose.
Start with a comfortable budget. Curiosity does not need to begin with the most expensive specimen.
Seven questions before your next discovery
Tay’s original reflection introduces the 5W2H approach. Here is a collecting version you can use with a child, a friend or your own growing collection:
- What? Do I know what I want this specimen to add to my collection?
- Why? Would I still enjoy it if nobody else were impressed?
- When? Is this a sensible time to buy within my collecting budget?
- Where? Do I have a suitable place to keep or display it?
- Who? Have I considered the person who will own, handle or receive it?
- How? Do I understand how to handle and care for this particular specimen?
- How much? Am I comfortable with the full cost, including any tools or storage I need?
If an answer is unclear, ask us. A useful question is part of the discovery.
Look closer, then keep a little record
Before adding a piece to your collection, take time to observe its colour and shape. Notice what you can see with your eyes, then explore further with a suitable magnifier or loupe.
Keep the specimen’s label and any information supplied with it. Add a few notes about why you chose it and what you would like to learn next. If it is a gift, those observations can become part of its story.
A growing collection can record a growing curiosity.
Begin with one discovery
Explore our Gemstone Discovery Bags for a surprise specimen to start a collection, or browse our collecting tools for a closer look. You can also explore the shop and choose a piece that catches your attention.
For more opportunities to learn, visit The Gem Museum and explore its current activities and workshops.
Choose something you enjoy, understand what you are choosing and leave room for your next discovery.
Adapted from Tay Kunming’s reflection on gems, value and purpose.